How the calculator compares them
A fair comparison holds your paycheck steady. A Roth dollar costs you a dollar of take-home; a traditional dollar costs less, because it comes out before income tax. So for the same take-home, you can put more in traditional. The calculator does that, grows both at the same rate, and then compares a typical year in retirement (once Social Security starts) after federal and state income tax, using this year's brackets, the 65-and-over deduction, and the rules for taxing Social Security. Everything is in today's dollars.
If traditional would push you past the $25,500 IRS limit, the extra take-home goes to a regular brokerage account instead. That's why Roth tends to win for people who max out: the same limit holds more after-tax money.
What federal employees often miss
- Your pension fills the bottom brackets. A FERS annuity and Social Security are taxable income, so every traditional dollar you take out lands on top of them. Up to 85% of Social Security becomes taxable as your other income rises, which can push the real rate on traditional withdrawals above your bracket.
- You already have traditional money. Your agency's 1% and match always go to traditional, so choosing Roth for your own contributions gives you a mix, not all Roth.
- Roth balances have no required minimum distributions. Traditional balances do, from 73 (75 if born in 1960 or later), whether you need the money or not.
- The 5-year rule. Roth earnings are tax-free once 5 years have passed since January 1 of the year of your first Roth TSP contribution and you're 59½ (or disabled). A small Roth contribution now starts the clock.
- Leaving early can change the answer. If you separate in or after the year you turn 55 (50 for law enforcement, firefighters, and air traffic controllers), traditional withdrawals avoid the 10% penalty, but Roth earnings still need the 5-year-and-59½ test to be tax-free.
Roth in-plan conversions
Since January 2026 you can move money from your traditional TSP balance to Roth inside your account. The converted amount is added to your taxable income that year, and the tax has to come from other money (there is no withholding, so you may need estimated payments). The minimum is $500, you can convert up to 26 times a year, and a conversion can't be reversed. Each conversion starts its own 5-year clock for the 10% penalty if you're under 59½. Conversions tend to make sense in low-income years: after you retire and before Social Security and required distributions begin.
Questions
Is Roth or traditional TSP better?
It depends on one comparison: your tax rate now versus your tax rate when you take the money out. If your rate in retirement will be higher, Roth comes out ahead; if it will be lower, traditional does; if they are the same, they come out even for the same cost to your paycheck. A FERS pension and Social Security fill the low brackets in retirement, which is why many federal employees end up with a retirement tax rate closer to their working rate than they expect.
Does the agency match go into Roth TSP?
No. All agency and service contributions (the automatic 1% and the match) go into your traditional balance, even when your own contributions are Roth. Roth contributions are matched the same as traditional ones.
When are Roth TSP withdrawals tax-free?
Your Roth contributions always come out tax-free. The earnings are tax-free when they are "qualified": at least 5 years have passed since January 1 of the year of your first Roth TSP contribution, and you are at least 59½, permanently disabled, or deceased.
Can I convert traditional TSP to Roth?
Yes. Since January 2026 the TSP offers Roth in-plan conversions to current and separated participants. The minimum is $500, you can do up to 26 a year, and the amount converted is taxable income that year. You must pay the tax from other money (it can’t come out of the conversion), there is no withholding, and a conversion can’t be undone. Each conversion has its own 5-year clock for the 10% early withdrawal penalty.
Do I have to make Roth catch-up contributions?
Only if your pay from your agency was over the IRS threshold the year before: $150,000 of 2025 wages for 2026 catch-ups, $155,000 of 2026 wages for 2027. Then catch-ups (anything over the $25,500 limit) must be Roth. Below the threshold you can choose.
Does Roth TSP have required minimum distributions?
No. Since 2024 Roth TSP balances aren’t subject to required minimum distributions during your life. Traditional balances are, starting at 73 (75 if you were born in 1960 or later).
Can I split my TSP between Roth and traditional?
Yes. You can put any share of your contributions in each, and change it whenever you want in your payroll system. The limit applies to both together.
Sources: TSP, Traditional and Roth TSP contributions and Roth in-plan conversions; IRS Notice 2026-66 (limits and the Roth catch-up threshold); IRS Rev. Proc. 2025-32 (brackets); 26 U.S.C. 86 (Social Security). Left out: the FERS supplement, COLAs, IRMAA, tax credits, and pay raises. This is an estimate, not tax advice.
See your whole TSP at retirement with the TSP calculator, your pension with the FERS retirement calculator, and what you'll actually take home with the retirement take-home pay calculator.