FEHB Open Season is open through Dec 14. Get the free 2027 cheat sheet

Stay or Leave? Your Federal Job vs a Private Offer

What leaving now costs you in retirement (pension, supplement, and FEHB for life) and what an offer has to pay to make up for it.

Reviewed by Erin · Tested by federal employees and military members
Figures from OPM and OPM · Updated · How we check

Quick answer: Leaving before you can retire usually costs more than people expect, because you give up FEHB in retirement as well as pension. In our example (46 years old, 18 years in, $100,000, planning to retire at 60), staying is worth about $438,231 more in today's dollars, so a private offer would need about $137,546 a year to come out even.

$
$

Compared with the TSP's 5% from your agency.

Your FEHB plan in retirement (2027)

The government pays $1,663 a month of this plan for retirees. You keep that only with an immediate retirement.

$

Sets the FERS supplement if you retire before 62.

More assumptions

What money could safely earn above inflation.

The bottom line, in today's dollars

Staying comes out ahead by $90,392

To match staying, an offer would need to pay about $137,546 a year (with its 4% match).

If you stay and retire 6/2040

Immediate retirement, unreduced at 60

  • Pension$2,549/mo · $342,633
  • FERS supplement to 62$25,023
  • FEHB for life (government share)$239,558
  • Retirement value today$607,214

If you leave now

Deferred retirement (pension starts at 62), starting at 62

  • Pension$1,381/mo · $168,983
  • FEHB in retirementlost
  • Retirement value today$168,983
  • Offer's extra pay until 2040+$347,839
If you stay: see your monthly take-home in retirement and get your free Retirement Package →
  • Leaving gives up $438,231 of retirement value: the bigger, earlier pension, the supplement, and all of the FEHB government share for life.
  • With a deferred annuity you can't keep FEHB, FEGLI, or dental and vision in retirement (OPM).
  • You keep your TSP either way. Not counted: health insurance costs at the new job, job security, and leave.

An estimate in today's dollars: 2.5% inflation, FERS COLAs (none before 62 for regular retirees), a 3% real discount rate, to age 85. Your agency's annuity estimate is the official number.

Get the free FERS retirement checklist: every step and deadline before you retire.

What's next

Free: your Retirement Package

Your pension, supplement, Social Security, taxes, FEHB, and take-home in every phase of retirement, in a report you can print.

Build my report

$29 handbook

The 2027 Federal Employee Benefits Playbook

Every federal benefits decision for the year ahead, in one sequence: pay and the 2027 raise, FEHB and Medicare, the TSP, and FERS retirement.

See what's inside

Questions

What do I give up if I leave federal service early?

The pension you would have earned by staying (more years and a higher high-3), the right to start it before 62, the FERS supplement, and above all FEHB in retirement: with a deferred annuity you can't keep FEHB, FEGLI, or FEDVIP. You keep your TSP and a deferred pension at 62 for the years you served.

How much more does a private job need to pay?

It depends on how close you are to retirement. In our example (age 46 with 18 years, planning to retire at 60), staying is worth about $438,231 more in retirement, so a private offer would need to pay about $137,546 a year, versus $100,000, just to break even.

Can I keep FEHB if I leave before retirement?

Only with an immediate retirement (including MRA+10, even if you postpone it) and 5 years of FEHB right before you leave. A deferred annuity, taken when you leave before you're eligible to retire, doesn't carry FEHB.

What is a deferred annuity?

If you leave with at least 5 years but before you can retire, you can collect a FERS pension at 62 (or at your MRA with 10+ years, reduced). It's based on your service and high-3 when you left, and there's no supplement or FEHB.

More: FERS retirement calculator, take-home pay in retirement, FEHB premiums.

Sources: OPM FERS computation and types of retirement; OPM annuitant FEHB rules (no FEHB with a deferred annuity; 5-year rule); 5 U.S.C. 8462 (FERS COLA); OPM FEHB premium tables. Checked November 16, 2026.